Founders Jaanus Juss and Hardi Meybaum first explored interactive storytelling with live theater, where they had developed a way for audiences to chime with table-side devices. They eventually realized they could replicate that experience with smartphones, where groups of friends could get together to debate plot lines and the direction of the story.
I’ll say this up front: I’m a bit of a mark for interactive storytelling. I’ve genuinely loved Telltale’s games and the Life is Strange series. And while Bandersnatch was a tad over-hyped, I still enjoyed the experience of controlling my own Black Mirror episode. So it wasn’t a huge surprise when I found myself instantly engrossed in my first Whatifi experience, As Dead as it Gets.
What starts out as a drunken night with a few bros quickly veers into supernatural fantasy reminiscent of the excellent Showtime series Dead Like Me. You step into the shoes of characters on the verge of death, whose only way back to the land of the living is to follow the advice of a few ghosts. It’s all so engrossing, I barely noticed I was staring at vertical video for several minutes, an orientation that makes it easier to make narrative choices.
At key moments in the film, you can choose from one of two outcomes by swiping up or down. If you’re viewing with friends using Whatifi’s watch party feature, those decisions are polled together. And if you all don’t agree, you’re forced to argue with friends until you reach a consensus. I wasn’t able to try out the social experience during my preview, but I can imagine having a blast arguing about some of the choices. Before I knew it, I had spent 45 minutes exploring multiple paths in As Dead as it Gets.
Once you reach the end of a story in Whatifi, you can easily restart the experience and jump right to decision points to unlock more endings. The service only has two films at launch, Anatomy of a Decision along with As Dead as it Gets, but together they have over 80 endings and 30 hours of video to watch. So even though a single playthrough may take 10 to 15 minutes, there’s a ton of replay value. While Whatifi is launching for free, the founders tell me they could eventually introduce a model where you can unlock more endings for an additional fee.